Logical Reasoning, Crows, and the Trap Tube Task


New research shows that wild New Caledonian crows can compete with 7-year-old children when it comes to understanding causality, or how one action causes another.

[T]here’s a widely used experiment called the trap-tube task. An animal uses a stick to push or pull a food reward out of a transparent tube, avoiding a small well in the center of the tube where the food would become stuck.

In the first experiment, the researchers replicate an earlier finding that the crows preferentially drop stones into water rather than sand to retrieve their snack. The second and third experiments pitted heavier and lighter objects, and solid blocks against hollow ones. The fourth experiment pitted narrow tubes against wide ones.

The New Caledonian crows actually did pretty well on all of these but the fourth, which they succeeded at, but not in a way that proved they understood the principle.

After these (and a fifth variation similar to the fourth) the researchers attempted a “U-Tube” task, with three tubes, the center being too narrow to drop anything into but having the treat.

Since the tubes were connected, the solution was to drop objects into one of the side tubes – but only one.

Eight year old children can figure this out, but apparently not any of the New Caledonian crows, who just kept dropping objects into both of the side tubes.

Via io9.

This entry was posted in Science, Videos by Heretic. Bookmark the permalink.

About Heretic

I design video games for a living, write fiction, political theory and poetry for personal amusement, and train regularly in Western European 16th century swordwork. On frequent occasion I have been known to hunt for and explore abandoned graveyards, train tunnels and other interesting places wherever I may find them, but there is absolutely no truth to the rumor that I am preparing to set off a zombie apocalypse. Nothing that will stand up in court, at least. I use paranthesis with distressing frequency, have a deep passion for history, anthropology and sociological theory, and really, really, really hate mayonnaise. But I wash my hands after the writing. Promise.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s